Choosing between a Honda Activa and an electric scooter has become a more challenging decision in recent years due to the increasing availability of electric options. To simplify the decision-making process, it's crucial to evaluate the cost components involved, including acquisition cost, fuel cost, and maintenance cost. While resale value is not considered here due to its complexity, the durability of the vehicles will be discussed.
Acquisition Cost: Honda Activa vs. Electric Scooter
In terms of acquisition cost, opting for an Activa would be a more budget-friendly choice. The Activa 110 comes in different variants, namely Standard, DLX, and H-Smart, with prices ranging from approximately Rs 75,347 to 81,348. Considering an on-road price of around Rs 90,000, substantial savings of up to Rs 30,000 can be achieved. These savings can be utilized for purchasing accessories for the scooter, indulging in other expenses like electronics, clothing, or travel, or even invested in equity or fixed deposits.
Within a budget of Rs 1.20 lakh, popular electric scooter options include Ola S1 Air, Ola S1, Ather 450X, TVS iQube & iQube S, Bajaj Chetak, and Hero Vida V1 Plus & V1 Pro. Opting for lower-spec variants of these electric scooters could potentially save some money from the budget.
For example, the most affordable option is the Ola S1 Air priced at Rs 84,999, followed by the Ather 450X at Rs 98,079. The effective price of the Vida V1 Plus is around Rs 1.03 lakh, while the TVS iQube starts at Rs 1.06 lakh. The Bajaj Chetak is available at a starting price of Rs 1.11 lakh.
Fuel Cost: Activa vs. Electric Scooter
The cost of petrol and electricity varies across states, but in general, electric scooters offer significant savings in fuel costs compared to Activa. In Delhi, petrol prices are around Rs 97 per litre. Assuming Activa's average fuel efficiency at approximately 50 km per litre, the running cost would be roughly Rs 1.9 per km. On the other hand, electric scooters have much lower running costs. For instance, the Ola S1 Pro claims just 17 paisa per kilometer, indicating substantial savings with an electric scooter.
Maintenance Cost: Activa vs. Electric Scooter
Due to their simpler design with fewer moving parts, electric scooters typically require less maintenance compared to petrol-powered scooters like the Activa. However, metal-bodied scooters like the Honda Activa have proven durability and can last over a decade, often retaining decent resale value. Electric scooters are still undergoing tests to determine their lifespan, and by 2030, a clearer understanding of their durability will emerge.
Other factors to consider include the cost of battery replacement. Battery packs are the most expensive components of electric scooters, and most manufacturers offer a warranty of 3 years. While the battery will continue to function beyond this period, its range may gradually decrease. Replacing the battery pack after 4-5 years could negate some of the savings achieved through lower fuel costs.
Considering Future Technological Advancements
As advancements in technology are expected in the future, it might be wise to wait a few years before experimenting with electric vehicles. Upcoming electric scooters equipped with battery swapping technology, such as Gogoro, could potentially revolutionize the market. For those who are financially conservative, opting for the Activa might be a safer choice. However, if budget is not a constraint, embracing the new experiences offered by an electric scooter could be desirable.
In conclusion, while the Honda Activa provides cost advantages in terms of acquisition and durability, electric scooters offer significant savings in fuel costs and reduced maintenance requirements. Assessing individual preferences, financial capabilities, and considering the future trajectory of electric vehicle technology will aid in making an informed decision.
